PROCEEDINGS OF THE COCHISE COUNTY PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING HELD ON
Wednesday, NOVEMBER 8, 2023
- Present:
- Kim DePew, Chair; Robert Montgomery, Vice Chair; Jim Martzke, Member; Albert Young, Member; Randall Limbach, Member
- Absent:
- Nathan Watkins, Member; Nancy Welch, Member; Gerry Gonzalez, Member; Larry Saunders, Member
- Staff Present:
-
- Dan Coxworth, Development Services Director
- Christine McLachlan, Planning Division Manager
- Matthew Taylor, Planner II
- Paul Correa, Civil Deputy County Attorney
- Attendees:
-
- Jacob Linde, Applicant (RZ 23-18)
- Phyllis Peachy, Applicant (RZ 23-20)
- Virginia Powell, Applicant (RZ 23-20)
- Joseph Lewis , Applicant SU 23-25
- Emilie Vardaman , Member of public opposed to SU 23-25
- Christopher Willheitte , Member of public in support of SU 23-25
- Genelle McCrary , Member of public opposed to SU 23-25
- Sarah Oliff , Member of public opposed to SU 23-25
- James Terry , Member of public opposed to SU 23-25
- Renee Reed , Member of public opposed to SU 23-25
- Brett Austin , Member of public in support of SU 23-25
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
THE ORDER OR DELETION OF ANY ITEM ON THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO MODIFICATION AT THE MEETING
Chair DePew requested moving the order of items on the agenda. She stated the applicant for item 5, SU 23-26 special use authorization for a solar energy power plant and Battery energy storage system, has requested that item be tabeled until the December 13th meeting. Commissioner Limbach made a motion to move item 5 on the agenda and table until the December commission meeting. Commissioner Martzke seconded. Motion passed 5-0.
Motion by Member Randall Limbach, Second by Member Jim Martzke Commissioner Young abstained due to absence at previous meeting
Vote: 4 - 0 Approved
The chair elected to move the item first on the agenda. She also stated that the applicant made a request to table this item until the December 13, 2023 regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission. Member Limbach made the motion to lay on the table, Member Martzke seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously (5-0) to lay on the table.
Motion by Member Jim Martzke, Second by Member Randall Limbach Case planner Taylor provided a presentation, which is preserved in the files. The applicant, Jacob Linde, was present to provide an applicant's statement. No one was present online or in person to support or oppose the request.
Commission discussion: Commissioner Young asked how close was the closest residence to the subject parcel. Case planner Taylor responded approximately 300 feet.
Staff recommended conditional approval. The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to provide a recommendation of conditional approval to the Board of Supervisors.
Vote: 5 - 0 Approved
Motion by Member Randall Limbach, Second by Member Jim Martzke Case planner McLachlan provided a presentation, which is preserved in the files. The applicant, Justin Uhrig, was not present to provide an applicant's statement. No one was present online or in person to support or oppose the request.
Commission discussion: Vice Chair Montgomery asked how far away was the nearest rural zoning. Case planner MCLachlan responded that it was 325' feet, and one parcel, west of this request. Young asked how close was the closest residence to the subject parcel. Case planner Taylor responded approximately 300 feet. Chair DePew asked about the permit status for the RV. Commissioner Limbach asked about the neighbor objections.
Staff recommended approval. The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to provide a recommendation of approval to the Board of Supervisors.
Vote: 5 - 0 Approved
Motion by Member Randall Limbach, Second by Vice Chair Robert Montgomery Case planner Taylor provided a presentation, which is preserved in the files. The applicant's daughter, Virginia Powell, was present to provide an applicant's statement. No one was present online or in person to support or oppose the request.
Staff recommended conditional approval. The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to provide a recommendation of conditional approval to the Board of Supervisors.
Vote: 5 - 0 Approved
Case planner Taylor provided a presentation, which is preserved in the files. The applicant, Joseph Lewis, was present to provide an applicant's statement.
The following members of the public spoke regarding the item: Emilie Vardaman (opposition), Christopher Willheitte (support), Genelle McCrary (opposition), Sarah Oliff (opposition), James Terry (opposition), Renee Reed (opposition), Brett Austin (support)
Member Limbach had concerns regarding site and parking security. Vice Chairman Montgomery also had security concerns about the proposal. He was also mentioned the neighbors' concerns regarding noise, lighting, and traffic. Member Young asked about the proposed hours of operation. Chair DePew questioned the applicant about the history of the site and previous rejections mentioned in the applicant's statement. She asked whether he would consider adjusting the hours of operation and applying for individual temporary use permits. She also requested to see the written petition in support of the proposal.
Staff recommended conditional approval. The commission voted unanimously (0-5) to deny the request.
Vote: 0 - 5 Disapproved
_____________________________________
Kim DePew, Chairman
ATTEST:
______________________________________
Daniel Coxworth, Development Services Director