Tabled from April 28, 2025
Certificate of Appropriateness PZCOA2025-00015
8-Plex Residential Development - 1204 Avenue E

Application submitted by agent Monique Neal on behalf of property owner Terry Coley, to construct an 8-plex residential development located on a designated historic site. The Parcel ID is 2404-823-0007-050-7.
The legal description of the property is: E L DAVIS` S/D LOTS 4, 5, 6-LESS S 5 FT AVE E RD R/W- AND WALLACE`S S/D E 86 FT OF LOT 8-LESS N 150 FT AND LESS S 5 FT AVE E RD R/W- (0.73 AC - 31,605 SF)

This eight-unit residential development is proposed at the northern edge of the Lincoln Park Historic District. The design of the new building meets the technical aspects of the Secretary of the Interior regarding size, scale and massing.

However, staff recommend that architectural features, such as decorative shutters, and differentiating color banding, be incorporated into the final design to better compose with the characteristics of the Lincoln Park Historic District. Also, large areas of solid blank wall should be avoided.

1204 AVENUE E Fort Pierce

Kev Freeman, Planning Director.

The Historic Preservation Board may:

• Approve the request as proposed

• Approve the request with a recommendation

• Deny the request