Skip to main content

AgendaQuick™

View Agenda Item

  
Item No. 3. 
MEETING DATE: 04/04/2022
 
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND COUNCILMEMBERS
 
FROM: JIM SADRO, CITY MANAGER
By:  Laurie Swindell, CMC, City Clerk

 
SUBJECT:
CONSIDER APPOINTMENT OF COMMISSIONERS AND ALTERNATES TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND THE COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION

RECOMMENDATION:


That the City Council consider:
A. Appointment of two individuals to the Planning Commission to fill one 4-year term that expired on March 31, 2021, and one unscheduled vacancy with a term expiring on March 31, 2023, and appoint two individuals as alternates;

B. Appointment of up to six individuals to the Community Services Commission to fill six terms as follows: two 3-year terms, two 2-year terms, and two 1-year terms, so the terms are staggered; and appoint two individuals as alternates; and,

C. Provide direction to staff regarding the reduction of the number of Community Services Commission positions from seven to five.

DISCUSSION:

On January 18, 2022, the City Council was notified of the following commission/committee vacancies:
  • One 4-year term on the Planning Commission that expired on March 31, 2021, but was extended one year to March 31, 2022, due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
  • Up to six vacancies on the Community Services Commission: two 3-year terms that expired on March 31, 2021, but were extended one-year to March 31, 2022, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and four 3-year term appointments that expire on March 31, 2022.
  • Due to City Council decreasing the size of the Beautification Committee from seven members to five members at the January 18, 2022, Regular Meeting, there are currently no vacancies to be filled; however, staff recommended appointing two alternates in the event a vacancy does occur over the next year.
At that time, City Council directed staff to advertise all expiring terms, and to schedule interviews, which were conducted at a Special City Council Meeting held on March 15, 2022.  A Commission opportunity notice was posted at City Hall and the City Council Chamber, and was also advertised on the City's Twitter and Facebook social media sites, the City website, on Channel 3, and in the local newspaper.  A total of 14 applications were received by or before the 5:00 p.m. deadline on February 17, 2022.

COMMISSION OPPORTUNITIES:

PLANNING COMMISSION: One 4-year term, one unscheduled vacancy, and two alternates should a vacancy occur within the next 12 months.  One term was set to expire March 31, 2021, but was postponed one year due to the COVID-19 pandemic.  The second term was an unscheduled vacancy that occurred on February 10, 2022, when the City Council appointed former Planning Commissioner Daren Nigsarian, whose term expires March 31, 2023, to the City Council vacancy left by the resignation of former City Councilmember Shaw. 
 

COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION: Up to six vacancies, including two extended 3-year terms and four 3-year term appointments on the Community Services Commission, as well as two alternates should a vacancy occur within the next 12 months. As an alternative, the City Council could direct staff to amend La Habra Municipal Code Section 2.28.040, which reads, "...The Community Services Commission shall consist of seven members appointed by the city council...." to reduce the number of Community Services Commissioners from seven members to five members. By doing so, City Council would be able to set the same number of seats (5) for all of its regular appointed commissions and committees.  If so directed, staff recommends not filling the two 1-year staggered seats, and to direct staff bring back a separate agenda item for City Council's consideration to amend the La Habra Municipal Code at a future date.

BEAUTIFICATION COMMITTEE: Due to City Council decreasing the number of Beautification Committee from seven members to five members on January 18, 2022, there are currently no vacancies to be filled.  Furthermore, since the two applicants who expressed an interest in being appointed as alternates did not show up for their interviews, the Beautification Committee does not have any eligible applicants available at this time to be assigned as alternates.
 
APPLICATIONS RECEIVED


Applicant
Date
Application
Received

Planning
Commission
Community
Services
Commission

Beautification
Committee
Matthew Matias 1/24/2022 X X  
Gabriela Garcia 1/27/2022   X  
Richard LaBounty 2/7/2022 X X  
Christopher Eastridge 2/7/2022 X    
Denise Schmidt 2/10/2022   X  
Esther Rojas(1) 2/20/2020 X    
Peter Cruz(1) 4/18/2021 X X  
Teresa Kempker(1) 2/16/2017   X  
Richard Rojas 2/14/2022   X  
Maria Mahecha 2/16/2022 X    
Carrie Surich 2/16/2022 X X  
John Fei 2/17/2022   X  
Pearl Arzate(1) 1/27/2021   X X
Luis Salazar(1) 2/1/2021     X
(1) In some cases, applicants requested to use applications that they had previously submitted, and that were already on file with the City.
 
Staff had scheduled interviews for the 14 applicants, which were held on March 15, 2022; all of which are listed below for reference.
INTERVIEW SCHEDULE
Time Applicant Commission(s) of Interest
5:00 p.m. Matthew Matias Planning Commission or Community Services Commission
5:10 p.m. Gabriela Garcia Community Services Commission
5:20 p.m. Richard La Bounty Planning Commission or Community Services Commission
5:30 p.m Christopher Eastridge * Planning Commission
5:40 p.m. Denise Schmidt Community Services Commission
5:50 p.m. Peter Cruz Planning Commission or Community Services Commission
6:00 p.m. Teresa Kempker Community Services Commission
6:10 p.m. Richard Rojas Community Services Commission
6:20 p.m. Maria Mahecha Planning Commission
6:30 p.m. Carrie Surich Planning Commission or Community Services Commission
6:40 p.m. John Fei Community Services Commission
6:50 p.m. Pearl Arzate * Community Services Commission or Beautification Committee
7:00 p.m. Luis Salazar * Beautification Committee
7:10 p.m. Esther Rojas Planning Commission

* Applicants who did not show up for their interview.

Terms and Term Limits – City Council policy allows for Planning Commissioners to serve two consecutive terms of four years each or a maximum of 10 years; and the Community Services Commissioners to serve three consecutive terms of three years each or a maximum of 10 years.

City Ordinance No. 1351 adopted on February 21, 1989, limits Planning Commissioners terms to four years, expiring March 31 and staggered; and the Community Services Commissioners terms to three years, expiring March 31 and staggered.  Term limits were not established by this ordinance.  Since term limits were set by City Council policy and not by ordinance, it is the opinion of the City Attorney that the City Council has the option to reappoint as they so choose.
 
HISTORY OF CURRENT COMMISSIONERS INTERESTED IN REAPPLYING:
PLANNING 
COMMISSION
(4-YEAR TERM)
APPOINTMENT
DATE
NOTE TERM
FROM
TERM
TO
TOTAL
YEARS/
MONTHS
Esther Rojas 7/12/2021   7/12/2021 3/31/2022 8.5 Months
COMMUNITY SERVICES
COMMISSION
(3-YEAR TERM)
APPOINTMENT
DATE
NOTE TERM
FROM
TERM
TO
YEARS
Carrie Surich * 3/3/2014   1/16/2018 3/31/2021 8 Years and
1 month
Gabriela Garcia 4/15/2019   4/15/2019 3/31/2022 2 Years and
11 Months
Denise Schmidt 4/15/2019   4/15/2019 3/31/2022 2 Years and
11 Months
Teresa Kempker 4/3/2017   1/16/2018 3/31/2021 5 Years
Richard Rojas 2/1/2021   2/1/2021 3/31/2022 1 Year and
2 Months

* Carrie Surich has expressed an interest in being appointed to the Planning Commission.
 
 

FISCAL IMPACT/SOURCE OF FUNDING:

The Planning Commissioners earn a monthly stipend of $100. The Community Services Commissioners earn a monthly stipend of $50. Beautification Committee members do not receive a stipend.

GENERAL PLAN RELEVANCE:

ED8
ED9
 

Attachments