![]() |
ITEM NO. 2c |
TOWN OF PRESCOTT VALLEY
STAFF REPORT

STAFF REPORT
DATE: 11/19/2026
TO: Mayor & Town Council
THROUGH: Gilbert Davidson, Town Manager
FROM:
DEPARTMENT: Town Manager's Office
AGENDA TYPE: Discussion Item(s)
SUBJECT: Possible Reconsideration of Recent Repeal of Ordinance No. 2023-930 Water Requirements Non-Subdivision Residential Developments - Consideration & Possible Action (Motion to Reconsider) [Councilmembers Freund, Kiehl & Thornton] - Added 11/18/26
TO: Mayor & Town Council
THROUGH: Gilbert Davidson, Town Manager
FROM:
DEPARTMENT: Town Manager's Office
AGENDA TYPE: Discussion Item(s)
SUBJECT: Possible Reconsideration of Recent Repeal of Ordinance No. 2023-930 Water Requirements Non-Subdivision Residential Developments - Consideration & Possible Action (Motion to Reconsider) [Councilmembers Freund, Kiehl & Thornton] - Added 11/18/26
| VISION 2024 FOCUS AREA: Water and Land Stewardship - Responsible planning for sustainable water management and land conservation. |
SUMMARY/BACKGROUND:
At last week’s regular Town Council meeting, Ordinance No. 2026-988 received its second reading by title only and was approved by a 4-3 vote. That Ordinance repealed earlier Ordinance No. 2023-930 that had adopted Town Code Article 14-07 related to Non-Subdivision Residential Developments. Ordinance No. 2026-988 will be effective 30 days after passage.
Municipal governing bodies have the inherent right to reconsider actions they take. [McQuillen Mun. Corp. §13.48 3rd Ed.] Section 27 of Robert’s Rules provides for reconsideration of actions by the next succeeding session. Motions to reconsider must be made by a Council member who voted with the prevailing side, but any member may second the motion. The effect of making a motion to reconsider is to suspend all action that the original motion would have required, and to place the original question in the exact position it occupied before it was voted on.
Town Code 2-04-020(A) provides for calling Special Meetings. This provision is also used to allow three Council members to request an agenda item at an upcoming meeting that has already been scheduled. Council members Freund, Kiehl, and Thornton have requested an agenda item be placed on this meeting to reconsider the vote taken on November 12th regarding Ordinance No. 2026-988. After discussion, if no motion is made by a member who voted previously with the majority, the matter ends.
Issues:
On January 11, 2024, the Town Council adopted Ordinance No. 2023-930 requiring non-subdivision residential developments in the Town to obtain commitments for renewable water supplies (i.e., effluent interests, available extinguishment credits, etc.) or imported water supplies as a condition precedent for any Town approvals (similar to what residential subdivisions are required to obtain to receive Certificates of Assured Water Supply from the Arizona Department of Water Resources (ADWR) because of the Town's location within the Prescott Active Management Area (AMA) and lack of being a Designated Provider). The basis and authority for adopting said Ordinance was set forth in extensive recitals that explained (among other things) the importance of reserving the remaining buffer of Assured Water Supply Program allocation (available since the 1999 ADWR declaration that the AMA was no longer in a state of safe groundwater yield) for true commercial, retail, industrial and governmental services.
Unfortunately, the Town has been notified by the Goldwater Institute that it believes Ordinance No. 2023-930 conflicted with the Arizona Groundwater Management Act. Goldwater also disagreed with the Town’s position that it had sufficient authority to enact the Ordinance. The Goldwater Institute requested that the Town Council consider rescinding the Ordinance or face litigation by affected property owners. This and other potential risks (including potential action under SB1487) led staff to recommend repealing Ordinance No. 2023-930 as requested in order to avoid potential long-lasting and divisive litigation that might be brought in relation to the policy Ordinance No. 2023-930 adopted regarding non-subdivision residential development.
Town staff has been clear that adoption of Ordinance No. 2023-930 was only one part of the Town's ongoing effort over many years to adopt a wide-ranging program of careful and prudent water management. The Town is committed to effective measures of water management now and in the future. In particular, the Town will seek state legislative action and otherwise work with interested parties locally and throughout the state to help advance a statewide and/or AMA solution. Staff is also in discussions about potential local initiatives related to zoning overlay districts that address water concerns.
Municipal governing bodies have the inherent right to reconsider actions they take. [McQuillen Mun. Corp. §13.48 3rd Ed.] Section 27 of Robert’s Rules provides for reconsideration of actions by the next succeeding session. Motions to reconsider must be made by a Council member who voted with the prevailing side, but any member may second the motion. The effect of making a motion to reconsider is to suspend all action that the original motion would have required, and to place the original question in the exact position it occupied before it was voted on.
Town Code 2-04-020(A) provides for calling Special Meetings. This provision is also used to allow three Council members to request an agenda item at an upcoming meeting that has already been scheduled. Council members Freund, Kiehl, and Thornton have requested an agenda item be placed on this meeting to reconsider the vote taken on November 12th regarding Ordinance No. 2026-988. After discussion, if no motion is made by a member who voted previously with the majority, the matter ends.
Issues:
On January 11, 2024, the Town Council adopted Ordinance No. 2023-930 requiring non-subdivision residential developments in the Town to obtain commitments for renewable water supplies (i.e., effluent interests, available extinguishment credits, etc.) or imported water supplies as a condition precedent for any Town approvals (similar to what residential subdivisions are required to obtain to receive Certificates of Assured Water Supply from the Arizona Department of Water Resources (ADWR) because of the Town's location within the Prescott Active Management Area (AMA) and lack of being a Designated Provider). The basis and authority for adopting said Ordinance was set forth in extensive recitals that explained (among other things) the importance of reserving the remaining buffer of Assured Water Supply Program allocation (available since the 1999 ADWR declaration that the AMA was no longer in a state of safe groundwater yield) for true commercial, retail, industrial and governmental services.
Unfortunately, the Town has been notified by the Goldwater Institute that it believes Ordinance No. 2023-930 conflicted with the Arizona Groundwater Management Act. Goldwater also disagreed with the Town’s position that it had sufficient authority to enact the Ordinance. The Goldwater Institute requested that the Town Council consider rescinding the Ordinance or face litigation by affected property owners. This and other potential risks (including potential action under SB1487) led staff to recommend repealing Ordinance No. 2023-930 as requested in order to avoid potential long-lasting and divisive litigation that might be brought in relation to the policy Ordinance No. 2023-930 adopted regarding non-subdivision residential development.
Town staff has been clear that adoption of Ordinance No. 2023-930 was only one part of the Town's ongoing effort over many years to adopt a wide-ranging program of careful and prudent water management. The Town is committed to effective measures of water management now and in the future. In particular, the Town will seek state legislative action and otherwise work with interested parties locally and throughout the state to help advance a statewide and/or AMA solution. Staff is also in discussions about potential local initiatives related to zoning overlay districts that address water concerns.
RECOMMENDED MOTION:
N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends ultimate repeal of prior Ordinance No. 2023-930 related to water requirements for non-subdivision residential development effective 30 days after November 12, 2026.
FISCAL ANALYSIS:
No direct fiscal impact related to this particular action. Future costs may be incurred for legal representation or other defense-related expenses depending on various scenarios related to effectiveness of Ordinance No. 2026-988.
