Consent-General Government # 26.
Board of Supervisors
General Services
- Meeting Date:
- 12/05/2023
- Brief Title
- Public Art at Leinberger and Monroe Detention Facilities
From:
Ryan Pistochini, Director of General Services, General Services Department
Staff Contact:
Alison Flory, Executive Director, YoloArts, 530-309-6464
Supervisorial District Impact:
District 3
Subject
Approve public art proposal recommendations from the Art Advisory Committee for Monroe Detention Center and Leinberger Memorial Center and delegate authority to the Director of General Services to sign and execute contracts as necessary to implement the art proposals. (No general fund impact) (Pistochini/Flory)
Recommended Action
- Approve public art proposal recommendations from the Art Advisory Committee for Monroe Detention Center and Leinberger Memorial Center; and
- Delegate authority to the Director of General Services to sign and execute contracts as necessary to implement the art proposals, provided there are no significant programmatic changes or increases in funding.
Strategic Plan Goal(s)
| Thriving Residents | |
| Safe Communities | |
| Robust Economy |
Reason for Recommended Action/Background
The Board of Supervisors' policy for Art in Public Places (Attachment A) requires that a percent of all new construction be set aside to fund an art project for a new facility. For the Monroe Detention Center and Leinberger Memorial Center projects, 0.4% of the construction budget, $230,500, was reserved for art projects. On April 12th, 2022, the Board of Supervisors received and reviewed the art plan for Monroe Detention Center and Leinberger Memorial Center which then served as the basis for a Request for Qualifications (RFQ), provided in Attachment B, that was released to solicit qualifications from artists nationwide.
The RFQ was released on September 22nd, 2022, and 77 submissions were received. Of those submissions, 30 met the basic requirements and were reviewed by the Art Advisory Committee established for this project. This committee comprised the following individuals:
Supervisor Jim Provenza, District 4
Supervisor Angel Barajas, District 5
Manuel Rios, Associate Professor, Woodland Community College, and Artist
Julie Salley, Board of Directors, YoloArts
Susanna Tu, Sacramento Office of Arts and Culture
Tina Day, Yolo County Sheriff’s Department
Tom Lopez, Sheriff, Yolo County Sheriff’s Department
The Committee intended to review the qualifications and site-specific design proposals before determining the total number of pieces to be commissioned. Therefore, artists had the opportunity to submit proposals amounting to less than the total budget. Upon review of the 30 artist qualifications, the Committee selected 6 artists to provide site-specific design proposals for a $1,000 stipend. Of the six site-specific design proposals, the Committee is recommending commissioning three artists. Joseph Bellacera, James Dinh and Kenneth McCall were chosen as the artists by the Committee. Bellacera’s proposal (Attachment C) will place an art installation on the interior lobby wall of Leinberger Memorial Center at the cost of $27,000. Dinh’s proposal (Attachment C) will place an art installation in the exterior landscape at the entrance of Leinberger Memorial Center at the cost of $100,000. McCall’s proposal (Attachment C) will place an art installation on the exterior of the Monroe Detention Center entry at the cost of $73,500.
These proposals met the required thematic elements, such as its reflection of the community, met safety requirements, and required minimal ongoing maintenance. Project costs as outlined by the artists include all design, engineering, fabrication, and installation of artwork, including all insurance, transportation and travel costs.
Next Steps
Upon Board approval of the Committee's art recommendation, contracts will be prepared with the artists which will include detailed stipulations regarding insurance coverage. Artwork installation is anticipated to occur in July 2024.
The RFQ was released on September 22nd, 2022, and 77 submissions were received. Of those submissions, 30 met the basic requirements and were reviewed by the Art Advisory Committee established for this project. This committee comprised the following individuals:
Supervisor Jim Provenza, District 4
Supervisor Angel Barajas, District 5
Manuel Rios, Associate Professor, Woodland Community College, and Artist
Julie Salley, Board of Directors, YoloArts
Susanna Tu, Sacramento Office of Arts and Culture
Tina Day, Yolo County Sheriff’s Department
Tom Lopez, Sheriff, Yolo County Sheriff’s Department
The Committee intended to review the qualifications and site-specific design proposals before determining the total number of pieces to be commissioned. Therefore, artists had the opportunity to submit proposals amounting to less than the total budget. Upon review of the 30 artist qualifications, the Committee selected 6 artists to provide site-specific design proposals for a $1,000 stipend. Of the six site-specific design proposals, the Committee is recommending commissioning three artists. Joseph Bellacera, James Dinh and Kenneth McCall were chosen as the artists by the Committee. Bellacera’s proposal (Attachment C) will place an art installation on the interior lobby wall of Leinberger Memorial Center at the cost of $27,000. Dinh’s proposal (Attachment C) will place an art installation in the exterior landscape at the entrance of Leinberger Memorial Center at the cost of $100,000. McCall’s proposal (Attachment C) will place an art installation on the exterior of the Monroe Detention Center entry at the cost of $73,500.
These proposals met the required thematic elements, such as its reflection of the community, met safety requirements, and required minimal ongoing maintenance. Project costs as outlined by the artists include all design, engineering, fabrication, and installation of artwork, including all insurance, transportation and travel costs.
Next Steps
Upon Board approval of the Committee's art recommendation, contracts will be prepared with the artists which will include detailed stipulations regarding insurance coverage. Artwork installation is anticipated to occur in July 2024.
Collaborations (including Board advisory groups and external partner agencies)
The General Services Department collaborated with the Yolo County Arts Council (YoloArts), the Yolo County Sheriff's Office, and the Yolo County Board of Supervisors Districts 4 and 5.
Competitive Bid Process/Vendor Performance
Request for Qualifications (RFQ) Service Requested: Art in Public Places - Monroe Detention Center and Leinberger Memorial Center
Evaluation Criteria Included in RFQ
Thematic Elements (8 points)
Artistic Merit (4 points)
Security Concerns (4 points)
Fabrication, Installation and Maintenance of Public Art (4 points)
Cost (4 points)
Bids Reviewed by Committee
Following the committee review of the 30 submissions of artist qualifications, the committee selected six artists to submit site-specific design proposals. A stipend of $1,000 was provided to the six artists: Mark Abildgaard, Joseph Bellacera, Scott Clendaniel, James Dinh, Kenneth McCall, and Sean Orlando. Design proposals were reviewed by the committee and three artists, Joseph Bellacera, James Dinh, and Kenneth McCall were selected for final recommendation.
Evaluation Criteria Included in RFQ
Thematic Elements (8 points)
Artistic Merit (4 points)
Security Concerns (4 points)
Fabrication, Installation and Maintenance of Public Art (4 points)
Cost (4 points)
Bids Reviewed by Committee
| Bidder | Bid | |
| Mark | Abildgaard | not provided |
| Daniel | Antelo | $90,000 |
| Jhonattan | Arango | $44/sqft |
| Solomon | Bassoff | $200,500 |
| Joseph | Bellacera | $150,000 |
| Resa | Blatman | $65,000-$150,000 |
| Addie | Boswell | $40,000 |
| Monika | Bravo | not provided |
| Sijia | Chen | $190,000 |
| Gail | Christofferson | $200,500 |
| Scott | Clendaniel | $66,000 |
| Roberto | Delgado | $125-$275/sqft |
| James | Dinh | $100,000-$150,000 |
| Angelina Melicia | Duckett | $105,000-$125,000 |
| Dina | Fisher | $200,500 |
| Catalina | Gonzalez | $80,000 |
| Cable | Griffith | not provided |
| BJ | Krivanek | $200,500 |
| Barry | Kulmann | not provided |
|
MJ |
Lindo-Lawyer |
$200,500 |
| Oleg | Lobykin | $200,000 |
| Kenneth | McCall | $200,500 |
| Sean | Orlando | $200,500 |
| Ene | Osteraas-Constable | $200,500 |
| Daniel | Roache | $125,000-$175,000 |
| Timothy | Smith | $200,500 |
| Rita | Soyfertis | not provided |
| Adrian | Susnea Litman | $106,700 |
| Madelyne | Templeton | $20-$30/sqft |
| Joshua | Wiener | $200,500 |
Following the committee review of the 30 submissions of artist qualifications, the committee selected six artists to submit site-specific design proposals. A stipend of $1,000 was provided to the six artists: Mark Abildgaard, Joseph Bellacera, Scott Clendaniel, James Dinh, Kenneth McCall, and Sean Orlando. Design proposals were reviewed by the committee and three artists, Joseph Bellacera, James Dinh, and Kenneth McCall were selected for final recommendation.
Fiscal Impact
Fiscal impact (see budgetary detail below)
Fiscal Impact (Expenditure)
- Total cost of recommended action:
- $ 230,500
- Amount budgeted for expenditure:
- $ 230,500
- Additional expenditure authority needed:
- $ 0
- One-time commitment:
- Yes
Source of Funds for this Expenditure
- Capital Project Funds
- $230,500
Further explanation as needed:
The entire budget for public art at this facility as set by the Yolo County Board of Supervisors is $230,500 and is appropriated in the overall budget for the Monroe Detention Center and Leinberger Memorial Center project. Of this amount, $30,000 has been set aside for consulting fees to YoloArts to develop and carry out the Art Plan. The remaining $200,500, plus any additional contributions toward the project, will be the amount allocated to pay for the selected artwork.
Project costs as outlined by the artists includes all design, engineering, fabrication and installation of artwork, including all insurance, transportation and travel costs. The artist/contractor will be required to sign a contract that will include detailed stipulations regarding insurance coverage.
Project costs as outlined by the artists includes all design, engineering, fabrication and installation of artwork, including all insurance, transportation and travel costs. The artist/contractor will be required to sign a contract that will include detailed stipulations regarding insurance coverage.
Attachments
Form Review
| Inbox | Reviewed By | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Ryan Pistochini (Originator) | Ryan Pistochini | 11/22/2023 01:16 PM |
| Ryan Pistochini (Originator) | Ryan Pistochini | 11/26/2023 05:37 PM |
| Financial Services | David Estrada | 11/28/2023 09:32 AM |
| County Counsel | Hope Welton | 11/28/2023 09:49 AM |
- Form Started By:
- Ryan Pistochini
- Started On:
- 11/20/2023 02:35 PM
- Final Approval Date:
- 11/28/2023